Spices as the saviour? The complex vulnerabilities of three commodity crop booms and ethnic minority livelihoods in Yunnan's agrarian frontier
Corresponding Author
Zhenting Zuo
Switzerland Research Center, Guizhou Normal University, Guiyang, Guizhou, 550001 China
Search for more papers by this authorJennifer C. Langill
Department of Geography, McGill University, Montréal, Québec, H3A 0B9 Canada
Search for more papers by this authorSarah Turner
Department of Geography, McGill University, Montréal, Québec, H3A 0B9 Canada
Search for more papers by this authorJean-François Rousseau
School of International Development and Global Studies, University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Ontario, K1N 6N5 Canada
Search for more papers by this authorCorresponding Author
Zhenting Zuo
Switzerland Research Center, Guizhou Normal University, Guiyang, Guizhou, 550001 China
Search for more papers by this authorJennifer C. Langill
Department of Geography, McGill University, Montréal, Québec, H3A 0B9 Canada
Search for more papers by this authorSarah Turner
Department of Geography, McGill University, Montréal, Québec, H3A 0B9 Canada
Search for more papers by this authorJean-François Rousseau
School of International Development and Global Studies, University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Ontario, K1N 6N5 Canada
Search for more papers by this authorAbstract
Commodity crops are redefining land use and rural smallholder livelihoods across Asia. These crops often have boom-bust cycles with important implications for the drivers of farmer entry into and exit from particular cash crop opportunities. This paper offers a comparative analysis of the boom-bust processes of three popular spice crops cultivated in Yunnan Province, southwest China. Drawing from agrarian frontiers and rural livelihoods literature, we disentangle the vulnerability contexts associated with black cardamom, cinnamon and star anise production, finding that farmers cultivating these spices face a combination of interlocking forms of vulnerability. Despite the monetary potential that each crop offered during its ‘boom’, the associated environmental, economic and political vulnerabilities caused most farmers to exit their production, responding with myriad on-farm and off-farm diversification strategies. Using a multi-sited ethnographic approach, we draw on 52 in-depth interviews with ethnic minority cultivators, spice traders and local government officials to untangle the complexities associated with cash crop production in this agrarian frontier, the interwoven vulnerabilities that result in their ‘busts’ and the coping and adaptation strategies that smallholder farmers employ. Our findings underline the importance of disaggregating farmer vulnerabilities and the need for more nuanced policy responses to adequately support small-scale farmers.
References
- Adger, N.W. (2006) Vulnerability, Global Environmental Change 16(3): 268–281.
- Agergaard, J., N. Fold and K.V. Gough (2009) Global–local interactions: Socioeconomic and spatial dynamics in Vietnam's coffee frontier, The Geographical Journal 175(2): 133–145.
- Aubertin, C. (2004) Cardamom (amomum spp) in Laos PDR: The hazardous future of an agroforest system product, in K. Kusters and B. Belcher (eds.), Forest products, livelihoods, and conservation: Case-studies of non-timber forest products systems. Bogor: CIFOR.
- Belton, B., I.J.M. van Asseldonk and S.R. Bush (2017) Domestic crop booms, livelihood pathways and nested transitions: Charting the implications of Bangladesh's Pangasius boom, Journal of Agrarian Change 17(4): 694–714.
- Borras, S.M.J., J. Liu, Z. Hu et al. (2018) Land control and crop booms inside China: Implications for how we think about the global land rush, Globalizations 15(1): 134–151.
- Bouahom, B., L. Douangsavanh and J. Rigg (2004) Building sustainable livelihoods in Laos: Untangling farm from non-farm, progress from distress, Geoforum 35(5): 607–619.
- Chambers, R. and G. Conway (1991) Sustainable rural livelihoods: Practical concepts for the 21st century. Brighton: Institute of Development Studies.
- Champalle, C. and S. Turner (2014) Cash crops and climate shocks: Flexible livelihoods and food security in Southeast Yunnan, China, Chinese Journal of Applied Anthropology 3(1): 47–78.
- Clough, Y., H. Faust and T. Tscharntke (2009) Cacao boom and bust: Sustainability of agroforests and opportunities for biodiversity conservation, Conservation Letters 2(5): 197–205.
- Cramb, R., V. Manivong, J.C. Newby, K. Sothorn and P.S. Sibat (2017) Alternatives to land grabbing: Exploring conditions for smallholder inclusion in agricultural commodity chains in Southeast Asia, Journal of Peasant Studies 44(4): 939–967.
- Crook, R.C. (2001) Cocoa booms, the legalisation of land relations and politics in Cote d'Ivoire and Ghana, IDS Bulletin 32(1): 35–45.
- De Haan, L. and A. Zoomers (2005) Exploring the frontier of livelihoods research, Development and Change 36(1): 27–47.
- Delang, C.O. and Z. Yuan (2015) China's grain for green program: A review of the largest ecological restoration and rural development program in the world. Cham: Springer.
10.1007/978-3-319-11505-4 Google Scholar
- Department for International Development (1999) Sustainable livelihoods guidance sheets. London: Department for International Development.
- Derks, A., S. Turner and N. Thúy Hạnh (2020) Bastard spice or champagne of cinnamon? Conflicting value creations along cinnamon commodity chains in northern Vietnam, Development and Change 51(3): 1–26. https://doi.org/10.1111/dech.12582
- Eilenberg, M. (2014) Frontier constellations: Agrarian expansion and sovereignty on the Indonesian-Malaysian border, Journal of Peasant Studies 41(2): 157–182.
- Ellis, F. (2000) Rural livelihoods and diversity in developing countries. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
10.1093/oso/9780198296959.001.0001 Google Scholar
- Fang, Q. (2005) 肉桂规范化种植(GAP)研究 [The Study on Good Agriculture Practice(GAP) of Cinnamomum Cassia Presl]. MA Thesis, Guangzhou University of Traditional Chinese Medicine.
- Filipski, M., A. Aboudrare, T.J. Lybbert and J.E. Taylor (2017) Spice price spikes: Simulating impacts of saffron price volatility in a gendered local economy-wide model, World Development 91: 84–99.
- Gatto, M., M. Wollni and M. Qaim (2015) Oil palm boom and land-use dynamics in Indonesia: The role of policies and socioeconomic factors, Land Use Policy 46: 292–303.
- Goodman, D.S.G. (2004) The campaign to ‘open up the west’: National, provincial-level and local perspectives, The China Quarterly 178: 317–334.
- Griffin, C. (2020) ‘Prosperity beyond belief’: The interaction between a potato crop boom, vulnerability and volcanic hazard in Central Java, Indonesia, Singapore Journal of Tropical Geography 41(1): 23–39.
- Ha, D.T. and G. Shively (2008) Coffee boom, coffee bust and smallholder response in Vietnam's central highlands, Review of Development Economics 12(2): 312–326.
- Hall, D. (2011a) Land grabs, land control, and southeast Asian crop booms, Journal of Peasant Studies 38(4): 837–857.
- Hall, D. (2011b) Where the streets are paved with prawns: Crop booms and migration in Southeast Asia, Critical Asian Studies 43(4): 507–530.
- Han, M.-Y. and D.-L. Ning (2006) 云南八角生产的主要问题分析及其对策 [Major problems and development strategy analysis on production of Illicium verum in Yunnan], Journal of West China Forestry Science 35(1): 125–128.
- Harrell, S. (1995) Cultural encounters on China's ethnic frontiers. Seattle: University of Washington Press.
- He, J. and T. Sikor (2015) Notions of justice in payments for ecosystem services: Insights from China's sloping land conversion program in Yunnan Province, Land Use Policy 43: 207–216.
- He, J. and T. Sikor (2017) Looking beyond tenure in China's collective forest tenure reform: Insights from Yunnan Province, southwest China, International Forestry Review 19(1): 29–41.
- He, J., B. Kebede, A. Martin and N. Gross-Camp (2020) Privatization or communalization: A multi-level analysis of changes in forest property regimes in China, Ecological Economics 174: 106629.
- Hekou County Government (2015) 河口瑶族自治县志 [County Annals of Hekou, Yunnan]. Yunnan: Yunnan People's Publishing House.
- Hekou County Government (2017) 河口瑶族自治县志 [County Annals of Hekou, Yunnan]. Yunnan: Yunnan People's Publishing House.
- Hervas, A. (2019) The Socio-Ecological Ramifications of Boom Crops: Examining the Impacts of Oil Palm Expansion Upon Food System Vulnerability in Northern Guatemala. Doctoral Dissertation, University of Toronto.
- Hervas, A. (2020) Cultivating vulnerability: Oil palm expansion and the socio-ecological food system in the Lachuá Ecoregion, Guatemala, Regional Environmental Change 20(2): 45.
- Johnston, R.J. (1995) Territoriality and the state, in G.B. Benko and U. Strohmayer (eds.), Geography, history and social sciences. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
10.1007/978-94-017-1681-9_14 Google Scholar
- Junquera, V. and A. Grêt-Regamey (2019) Crop booms at the forest frontier: Triggers, reinforcing dynamics, and the diffusion of knowledge and norms, Global Environmental Change 57: 101929.
- Kong, R., J.-C. Diepart, J.-C. Castella et al. (2019) Understanding the drivers of deforestation and agricultural transformations in the northwestern uplands of Cambodia, Applied Geography 102: 84–98.
- Lai, H.H. (2002) China's western development program: Its rationale, implementation, and prospects, Modern China 28(4): 432–466.
- Li, T.M. (2002) Local histories, global markets: Cocoa and class in Upland Sulawesi, Development and Change 33(3): 415–437.
- Li, T.M. (2014) Land's end: Capitalist relations on an indigenous frontier. Durham, London: Duke University Press.
10.1215/9780822376460 Google Scholar
- Liu, X. and L. Lyu (2020) Income and poverty gaps between Han and ethnic minorities in rural China, in T. Sicular, S. Li, X. Yue and H. Sato (eds.), Changing trends in China's inequality: Evidence, analysis, and prospects. New York: Oxford University Press.
10.1093/oso/9780190077938.003.0010 Google Scholar
- Ma, J. (2013) The land development game in China. Lanham: Lexington Books.
- Mahanty, S. and S. Milne (2016) Anatomy of a boom: Cassava as a ‘gateway’ crop in Cambodia's north eastern borderland, Asia Pacific Viewpoint 57(2): 180–193.
- Martin, S.M. and K. Lorenzen (2016) Livelihood diversification in rural Laos, World Development 83: 231–243.
- McSweeney, K. (2004) The dugout canoe trade in Central America's Mosquitia: Approaching rural livelihoods through systems of exchange, Annals of the Association of American Geographers 94(3): 638–661.
- Meyfroidt, P., K.M. Carlson, M.E. Fagan et al. (2014) Multiple pathways of commodity crop expansion in tropical forest landscapes, Environmental Research Letters 9(7): 074012.
- Michaud, J., M.B. Ruscheweyh and M.B. Swain (2016) Historical dictionary of the peoples of the south-east Asian Massif, Second edn. London: Rowman & Littlefield.
- Nelson, D.R., W.N. Adger and K. Brown (2007) Adaptation to environmental change: Contributions of a resilience framework, Annual Review of Environment and Resources 32(1): 395–419.
- OECD (2011) Agricultural policy monitoring and evaluation 2011 OECD countries and emerging economies. Paris: OECD Publishing.
10.1787/agr_pol-2011-en Google Scholar
- Ribot, J.C. and N.L. Peluso (2003) A theory of access, Rural Sociology 68(2): 153–181.
- Rigg, J. (2006) Land, farming, livelihoods, and poverty: Rethinking the links in the rural south, World Development 34(1): 180–202.
- Rousseau, J.-F. and S. Turner (2018) Not at all costs: Frontier modernization schemes and ethnic minority livelihood debates in the Sino-Vietnamese borderlands, Verge: Studies in Global Asias 4(1): 133–159.
10.5749/vergstudglobasia.4.1.0133 Google Scholar
- Rousseau, J.-F. and Y. Xu (2020) The perfect storm: Extreme weather events and speculation along cardamom commodity chains in southwest China, Eurasian Geography and Economics. https://doi.org/10.1080/15387216.2020.1792323
- Rousseau, J.-F., S. Turner and Y. Xu (2019) Cardamom casualties: Extreme weather events and ethnic minority livelihood vulnerability in the Sino-Vietnamese borderlands, Climate 7(1): 14.
- Scott, J. (1985) Weapons of the weak: Everyday forms of peasant resistance. London: Yale University Press.
- Scott, J. (2009) The art of not being governed. An anarchist history of upland Southeast Asia. New Haven, Connecticut and London: Yale University Press.
- Shrestha, N.R., R.P. Velu and D. Conway (1993) Frontier migration and upward mobility: The case of Nepal, Economic Development and Cultural Change 41(4): 787–816.
- Sowerwine, J. (2004) Territorialisation and the politics of highland landscapes in Vietnam: Negotiating property relations in policy, meaning and practice, Conservation and Society 2(1): 97–135.
- Sturgeon, J.C., N.K. Menzies, Y.F. Lagerqvist et al. (2013) Enclosing ethnic minorities and forests in the golden economic quadrangle, Development and Change 44(1): 53–79.
- Su, X., X. Jiang, R. Liu, X. Mo, S. He and L. Guo (2019) 八角主要病虫害发生规律研究 [The regularity of the main insect pests and diseases of Illicium verum], Journal of Anhui Agricultural Sciences 47(2): 132–134.
- Taylor, P. (2016) Frontier commoditisation in post-socialist Southeast Asia, Asia Pacific Viewpoint 57(2): 145–153.
- Thulstrup, A.W. (2015) Livelihood resilience and adaptive capacity: Tracing changes in household access to capital in central Vietnam, World Development 74: 352–362.
- Tsing, A.L. (2003) Natural resources and capitalist frontiers, Economic and Political Weekly 38(48): 5100–5106.
- Turner, S., C. Bonnin and J. Michaud (2015) Frontier livelihoods: Hmong in the Sino-Vietnamese borderlands. Seattle, London: University of Washington Press.
- Turner, S., A. Derks and N. Thúy Hạnh (2019) Flex crops or flex livelihoods? The story of a volatile commodity chain in upland northern Vietnam, Journal of Peasant Studies 46(2): 276–296.
- Vicol, M., B. Pritchard and Y.Y. Htay (2018) Rethinking the role of agriculture as a driver of social and economic transformation in Southeast Asia's upland regions: The view from Chin State, Myanmar, Land Use Policy 72: 451–460.
- Weyerhaeuser, H., A. Wilkes and F. Kahrl (2005) Local impacts and responses to regional forest conservation and rehabilitation programs in China's northwest Yunnan province, Agricultural Systems 85(3): 234–253.
- Whitehead, A. (2002) Tracking livelihood change: Theoretical, methodological and empirical perspectives from north-east Ghana, Journal of Southern African Studies 28(3): 575–598.
- Xu, J. and J.C. Ribot (2004) Decentralisation and accountability in forest management: A case from Yunnan, southwest China, European Journal of Development Research 16(1): 153–173.
10.1080/09578810410001688789 Google Scholar
- Xu, J., E.T. Ma, D. Tashi, Y. Fu, Z. Lu and D. Melick (2005) Integrating sacred knowledge for conservation: Cultures and landscapes in southwest China, Ecology and Society 10(2): 7.
- Yeh, E.T. (2009) Greening western China: A critical review, Geoforum 40(5): 884–894.
- Yeh, E.T. (2013) The politics of conservation in contemporary rural China, The Journal of Peasant Studies 40(6): 1165–1188.
- Yin, D., J. Qian and H. Zhu (2019) Frontier development in the midst of ecological civilization: Unravelling the production of maca in Yunnan, China, Geoforum 106: 144–154.
- Zhou, D.Q. and R.E. Grumbine (2011) National parks in China: Experiments with protecting nature and human livelihoods in Yunnan province, People's Republic of China (PRC), Biological Conservation 144(5): 1314–1321.