AD536 – BACK TO NATURE?
John Moreland
Department of Archaeology, University of Sheffield, Minalloy House, 10–16 Regent Street, Sheffield, S1 3NJ UK
Search for more papers by this authorJohn Moreland
Department of Archaeology, University of Sheffield, Minalloy House, 10–16 Regent Street, Sheffield, S1 3NJ UK
Search for more papers by this authorABSTRACT
A spate of archaeological, historical and scientific publications have recently argued that the dust veil from a volcanic eruption (or series of eruptions) caused climatic change, which ‘forced’ significant historical transformations in the middle of the sixth century AD. In this paper, I situate this phenomenon within a more general return to environmental determinism in archaeological explanation, a return which itself needs to be understood in the context both of contemporary fears about the devastation to be unleashed by the climatic change we have made, and of the rise of precise measurement in environmental and archaeological science. I do not doubt the reality of the climatic change reconstructed for AD536/546 but, given the coarseness of the dating of the historical transformations, I do question the causal connections drawn between the former and the latter. I suggest that for many archaeologists, the AD536 event (and similar phenomena) functions much as written texts once did – as both the framework for analysis and as the explanation of historical process.
Primary sources
- Barnish, S. 1992. The Variae of Magnus Aurelius Cassiodorus Senator. Liverpool (Liverpool University Press).
10.3828/978-0-85323-436-4 Google Scholar
- Dewing, H.B. 1914–40. Procopius - History of the Wars. London (William Heinemann).
Webpages
- The Atlantic, June 2008 - https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2008/06/the-sky-is-falling/306807/
- Mail Online, 9th July 2015 - http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-3153753/Volcanic-eruptions-caused-freezing-temperatures-crop-failures-famine-early-Roman-times-changed-course-history.html
- National Geographic, 3rd February 2010
- National Geographic, https://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2010/02/100203-asteroid-collision-earth-global-cooling/
- Nature, 11th March 2008 - https://www.nature.com/news/2008/080311/full/news.2008.665.html
Printed publications
- Abbott, D., D. Breger, P. Biscaye, J. Barron, R. Juhl & P. McCafferty. 2014. What Caused Terrestrial Dust Loading and Climate Downturns between AD 533 and 540. Keller & Kerr 2014. 421–437.
- Andrén, A. 2005. Behind Heathendom: Archaeological Studies of Old Norse Religion. Scottish Archaeological Journal 27. 105–138.
10.3366/saj.2005.27.2.105 Google Scholar
- Andrén, A. 2012. From Sunset to Sunset. An Interpretation of Early Gotlandic Picture Stones. Herlin Karnell 2012. 49–58.
- Andrén, A. 2014. Tracing Old Norse Cosmology. The World Tree, Middle Earth, and the Sun in Archaeological Perspectives. Lund (Nordic Academic Press).
- Arjava, A. 2005. The Mystery Cloud of 536 CE in the Mediterranean Sources. Dumbarton Oaks Papers 59. 73–94.
10.2307/4128751 Google Scholar
- Armit, I., G.T. Swindles, K. Becker, G. Plunkett & M. Blaauw. 2014. Rapid Climate Change did not Cause Population Collapse at the End of the European Bronze Age. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 111. 17045–49.
- Arrhenius, B. 2013. Helgö in the Shadow of the Dust Veil 536–37. Journal of Archaeology and Ancient History 5. 1–14.
- Axboe, M. 1999. The Year 536 and the Scandinavian Gold Hoards. Medieval Archaeology 43. 186–88.
- Axboe, M. 2001. Amulet Pendants and a Darkened Sun. On the Function of the Gold Bracteates and a Possible Motivation for the Large Gold Hoards. Magnus 2001. 119–36.
- Baillie, M. 1991. Suck-in and Smear. Two Related Chronological Problems for the 90s. Journal of Theoretical Archaeology 2. 12–16.
- Baillie, M. 1999. Exodus to Arthur: Catastrophic Encounters with Comets. London (BT Batsford Limited).
- Baillie, M. 2006. New Light on the Black Death: The Cosmic Connection. Stroud (Tempus).
- Baillie, M. 2008. Proposed Re-dating of the European Ice Core Chronology by Seven Years Prior to the Seventh Century AD. Geophysical Research Letters 35. L15813.
- Baillie, M. & J. McAneney. 2015. Tree Ring Effects and Ice Core Acidities Clarify the Volcanic Record of the First Millennium. Climate of the Past 11. 105–14.
- Bampton, M., J. Kelley, A. Kelley, M. Jones & G. Bigelow. 2017. Little Ice Age Catastrophic Storms and the Destruction of a Shetland Island Community. Journal of Archaeological Science 87. 17–29.
- P. Biehl & O. Nieuwenhuyse (eds.). 2016. Cultural Change in Prehistoric Europe and the Near East. Albany (State University of New York).
- Binford, L. 1983. Objectivity – Explanation – Archaeology – 1981. Binford 1983. 45–55.
- Binford, L. 1983. Working at Archaeology. New York (Academic Press).
- Binford, L. 1989. In Pursuit of the Future. Binford 1989. 41–54.
- Binford, L. 1989. Debating Archaeology. New York (Academic Press).
- Breeze, A. 2016. Arthur's Battles and the Volcanic Winter of 536–37. Northern History 53. 161–72.
- Brown, P. 2013. The Rise of Western Christendom. Triumph and Diversity AD 200–1000. Chichester (John Wiley & Sons) (Revised Tenth Anniversary Edition).
- Buckland, P., A. Dugmore & K. Edwards. 1997. Bronze Age Myths? Volcanic Activity and Human Response in the Mediterranean and North Atlantic Regions. Antiquity 71. 581–93.
- Büntgen U., W. Tegel, K. Nicolussi, M. McCormick et al. 2011. 2500 Years of European Climate Variability and Human Susceptibility. Science 331. 578–82.
- Büntgen, U., V.S. Myglan, F.C. Ljungqvist, M. McCormick et al. 2016. Cooling and Societal Change During the Late Antique Little Ice Age from 536 to around 660AD. Nature Geoscience 9. 231–37.
- Büntgen, U. & N. Di Cosmo. 2016. Climate and Environmental Aspects of the Mongol Withdrawal from Hungary in 1242CE. Nature Scientific Reports 6. 25606.
- Carpenter, R. 1966. Discontinuity in Greek Civilisation. Cambridge (Cambridge University Press).
- Childe, G. 1942. What Happened in History. Middlesex (Penguin Books).
- Childe, G. 1950. The Urban Revolution. Town Planning Review 21. 3–17
10.3828/tpr.21.1.k853061t614q42qh Google Scholar
- Childe, G. 2003. Man Makes Himself. Nottingham (Spokesman) (originally published 1936).
- Collingwood, R.G. & J.N.L. Myres. 1937. Roman Britain and the English Settlements. Oxford (Oxford University Press).
- Cook, E. 2013. Megadroughts, ENSO, and the Invasion of Late-Roman Europe by the Huns and Avars. Harris 2013. 89–102.
- deMenocal, P. 2001. Cultural Responses to Climate Change During the Late Holocene. Science 292. 667–73.
- Drake, B. 2012. The Influence of Climate Change on the Late Bronze Age Collapse and the Greek Dark Ages. Journal of Archaeological Science 39. 1862–70.
- Dull, R., Southon, J. & P. Sheets. 2001. Volcanism, Ecology and Culture: A Reassessment of the Volcán Ilopango Tbj Eruption in the Southern Maya Realm. Latin American Antiquity 12. 25–44.
- Ferris, D.G., J. Cole-Dai, A.R. Reyes & D.M. Budner. 2011. South Pole Ice Core Record of Explosive Volcanic Eruptions in the First and Second Millennia AD and Evidence of a Large Eruption in the Tropics around 535AD. Journal of Geophysical Research 116. D17308.
- J.A. Franklin, T.A. Heslop & C. Stevenson (eds.). 2012. Architecture and Interpretation. Essays for Eric Fernie. Woodbridge (The Boydell Press).
- Fuks, D., O. Ackermann, A. Ayalon, M. Bar-Matthews et al. 2017. Dust Clouds, Climate Change and Coins: Consiliences of Palaeoclimate and Economy in the Late Antique Southern Levant. Levant 49. 205–23.
- Gräslund, B. & N. Price. 2012. Twilight of the Gods? The ‘Dust Veil Event’ of AD 536 in Critical Perspective. Antiquity 86. 428–43.
- Haldon, J. 2016. Cooling and Societal Change. Nature Geoscience 9. 191–92.
- Hamerow, H. 2002. Early Medieval Settlements. The Archaeology of Rural Communities in North-West Europe 400–900. Cambridge (Cambridge University Press).
- Hansen, J. 2015. Landsbydannelse og bebyggelsesstruktur i det 1. Årtusinde. Et bebyggelseshistorisk regionalstudie. PhD. Odense (Syddansk Universitet).
- Harper, K. 2017. The Fate of Rome. Climate, Disease, and the End of an Empire. Princeton (Princeton University Press).
10.2307/j.ctv9b2txr Google Scholar
- W.V. Harris (ed.). 2013. The Ancient Mediterranean Environment between Science and History. Leiden (Brill).
10.1163/9789004254053 Google Scholar
- Haug, G. et al. 2003. Climate and the Collapse of Maya Civilisation. Science 299. 1731–35.
- Herlihy, D. 1980. Climate and Documentary Sources. A Comment. The Journal of Interdisciplinary History 10. 713–17.
- M. Herlin Karnell (ed.). 2012. Gotland's Picture Stones. Bearers of an Enigmatic Legacy. Gotland Museum (Forsalen Publishing).
- D. Hinton (ed.). 1983. Twenty-Five Years of Medieval Archaeology. Sheffield (Society for Medieval Archaeology).
- Hirschfeld, Y. 2006. The Crisis of the Sixth Century. Climatic Change, Natural Disasters and the Plague. Mediterranean Archaeology and Archaeometry 6. 19–32.
- Hodges, R. 1982. Dark Age Economics. The Origins of Towns and Trade AD600–1000. London (Duckworth).
- Hodges, R. 1989. The Anglo-Saxon Achievement. Archaeology and the Beginnings of English Society. London (Duckworth).
- Izdebski, A., J. Pickett, N. Roberts & T. Waliszewski. 2016. The Environmental, Archaeological and Historical Evidence for Regional Climatic Changes and their Societal Impacts in the Eastern Mediterranean in Late Antiquity. Quaternary Science Reviews 136. 189–208.
- Kausrud, K.L., M. Begon, T. Ben Ari, H. Viljugrein et al. 2010. Modelling the Epidemiological History of Plague in Central Asia. Palaeoclimatic Forcing on a Disease System over the Past Millennium. BMC Biology 8. 112.
- G. Keller & A. Kerr (eds.). 2014. Volcanism, Impacts, and Mass Extinctions: Causes and Effects. Boulder (The Geological Society of America).
- Keys, D. 1999. Catastrophe. An Investigation into the Origins of the Modern World. New York (Ballantine Books).
- Larsen, L.B., B.M. Vinther, K.R. Briffa, T.M. Melvin et al. 2008. New Ice Core Evidence for a Volcanic Cause of the AD 536 Dust Veil. Geophysical Research Letters 35. L04708.
- L. Little (ed.). 2006. Plague and the End of Antiquity. The Pandemic of 541–750. Cambridge (Cambridge University Press).
10.1017/CBO9780511812934 Google Scholar
- Löwenborg, D. 2012. An Iron-Age Shock Doctrine – Did the AD 536–7 Event Trigger Large-Scale Social Changes in the Mälaren Valley Area? Journal of Archaeology and Ancient History 4. 1–29.
- Löwenborg, D. & P. Eriksson. 2015. Climate and the Definition of Archaeological Periods in Sweden. Biehl & Nieuwenhuyse 2016. 257–78.
- B. Magnus (ed.). 2001. Roman Gold and the Development of the Early Germanic Kingdoms. Stockholm (Almqvist & Wiksell).
- Malik, K. 2000. Man, Beast and Zombie. What Science Can and Cannot Tell Us about Human Nature. London (Weidenfeld and Nicholson).
- Manning, S. 2013. The Roman World and Climate: Context, Relevance of Climate Change, and Some Issues. Harris 2013. 103–70.
- Manning, J.G., F. Ludlow, A.R. Stine, W.R. Boos, M. Sigl & J.R. Marlon. 2017. Volcanic Suppression of Nile Flooding Triggers Revolt and Constrains Interstate Conflict in Ancient Egypt. Nature Communications 8. 900.
- McCormick, M., U. Büntgen, M.A. Cane, E.R. Cook et al. 2012. Climate Change During and After the Roman Empire. Reconstructing the Past from Scientific and Historical Evidence. Journal of Interdisciplinary History 43. 169–220.
- McMichael, A. 2010. Palaeoclimate and Bubonic Plague: A Forewarning of Future Risk? BMC Biology 8. 108.
- N. Miller, K. Moore & K. Ryan (eds.). 2011. Sustainable Lifeways. Cultural Persistence in an Ever-Changing Environment. Philadelphia (University of Pennsylvania Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology).
- Mitchell, J. 2012. Believing is Seeing. The Natural Image in Late Antiquity. Franklin, Heslop & Stevenson 2012. 16–41.
- J. Mitchell, J. Moreland & B. Leal (eds.). 2017. Encounters, Excavations and Argosies. Essays for Richard Hodges. Oxford (Archaeopress).
- Moreland, J. 2001. Archaeology and Text. London (Duckworth).
- Moreland, J. 2010. Archaeology, Theory and the Middle Ages. London (Duckworth).
- Moreland, J. 2017. Powerful Matter – Agency and Materiality in the Early Middle Ages. Mitchell, Moreland & Leal 2017. 217–35.
- J. Myrdal & M. Morell (eds.). 2011. The Agrarian History of Sweden: From 4000BC to AD2000. Lund (Nordic Academic Press).
- Näsman, U. 2012. Comments on “An Iron Age Shock Doctrine: The 536–37 Event as a Trigger of Large-Scale Social Change in the Mälaren Valley Area” by Daniel Löwenborg. Journal of Archaeology and Ancient History 4. 1–13.
- Nield, T. 2011. Incoming! Or, Why We Should Stop Worrying and Learn to Love the Meteorite. London (Granta Books).
- P.O. Nielsen, K. Randsborg & H. Thrane (eds.). 1994. The Archaeology of Gudme and Lundeborg. Copenhagen (Akademisk Forlag).
- Oppenheimer, C. 2011. Eruptions that Shook the World. Cambridge (Cambridge University Press).
10.1017/CBO9780511978012 Google Scholar
- Oppenheimer, C., A. Orchard, M. Stoffel, T.P. Newfield et al. 2018. The Eldgjá Eruption: Timing Long-Range Impacts and Influence of the Christianisation of Iceland. Climatic Change 147. 369–81.
- Pedersen, E.A. & M. Widgren. 2011. Agriculture in Sweden: 800BC – AD1000. Myrdal & Morell 2011. 46–71.
- Plunkett, G., C. McDermott, G.T. Swindles & D.M. Brown. 2013. Environmental Indifference? A Critique of Environmentally Deterministic Theories of Peatland Site Construction in Ireland. Quaternary Science Reviews 61. 17–31.
- Price, N. 2013. ‘Hard it is in the world'. Helgö and the Migration Period ‘Catastrophe Hypothesis’ – Comments to Birgit Arrhenius. Journal of Archaeology and Ancient History 5. 2–4.
- Price, N. & B. Gräslund. 2015. Excavating the Fimbulwinter? Archaeology, Geomythology and the Climate Event(s) of AD536. Riede 2015. 109–132.
- Randsborg, K. 1991. The First Millennium AD in Europe and the Mediterranean. Cambridge (Cambridge University Press).
- Randsborg, K. 1994. Gudme-Lundeborg. Interpretative Scenarios and Thoughts. Nielsen, Randsborg & Thrane 1994. 209–211.
- Randsborg, K. 1997. Treasure in History. Notes on the Migration Period. Acta Archaeologica 68. 195–207.
- Randsborg, K. 2015. Roman Reflections. Iron Age to Viking Age in Northern Europe. London (Bloomsbury Academic).
- F. Riede (ed.). 2015. Past Vulnerability. Vulcanic Eruptions and Human Vulnerability in Traditional Societies Past and Present. Aarhus (Aarhus University Press).
- Roberts, N. 2011. “Living with a Moving Target”: Long-Term Climatic Variability and Environmental Risk in Dryland Regions. Miller et al. 2011. 13–38.
- Salzer, M. & M. Hughes. 2007. Bristlecone Pine Tree Rings and Volcanic Eruptions over the Last 5000 Years. Quaternary Research 67. 57–68.
- Sherratt, A. 1995. Reviving the Grand Narrative. Archaeology and Long-Term Change. Journal of European Archaeology 3. 1–32.
10.1179/096576695800688223 Google Scholar
- Sigl, M., M. Winstrup, J.R. McConnell, K.C. Welten, G. Plunkett, F. Ludlow, U. Büntgen et al. 2015. Timing and Climate Forcing of Volcanic Eruptions for the Past 2,500 Years. Nature 523. 543–49.
- Sivertsen, B.J. 2009. The Parting of the Sea. How Volcanoes, Earthquakes, and Plagues Shaped the Story of Exodus. Princeton (Princeton University Press).
- Squatriti, P. 2010. The Floods of 589 and Climate Change at the Beginning of the Middle Ages. An Italian Microhistory. Speculum 85. 799–826.
- Stothers, R. 1999. Volcanic Dry Fogs, Climate Cooling, and Plague Pandemics in Europe and the Middle East. Climatic Change 42. 713–23.
- Stothers, R. 2000. Climatic and Demographic Consequences of the Massive Volcanic Eruption of 1258. Climatic Change 45. 361–74.
- Stothers, R. & M. Rampino. 1983. Volcanic Eruptions in the Mediterranean before AD630 From Written and Archaeological Sources. Journal of Geophysical Research 88. 6357–71.
- Symonds, J. 2017. Looking Beyond the Local: Richard Hodges’ Extraordinary Journey from Box to Butrint. Mitchell et al 2017. 7–20.
- Than, K. 2008. Comet Smashes Triggered “Dry Fog” Famine in 536 AD. New Scientist 201 (31.12.2008). 9.
10.1016/S0262-4079(09)60008-7 Google Scholar
- Toohey, M., K. Krüger, M. Sigl, F. Stordal & H. Svensen. 2016. Climatic and Societal Impacts of a Volcanic Double Event at the Dawn of the Middle Ages. Climatic Change 136. 401–12.
- Traufetter, F., H. Oerter, H. Fischer, R. Weller & H. Miller. 2004. Spatio-Temporal Variability in Volcanic Sulphate Deposition over the Last 2Kyr in Snow Pits and Firn Cores from Amundsenisen, Antarctica. Journal of Glaciology 50. 137–46.
- Trigger, B. 2006. A History of Archaeological Thought (second edition). Cambridge (Cambridge University Press).
10.1017/CBO9780511813016 Google Scholar
- Tvauri, A. 2012. The Migration Period, Pre-Viking Age, and Viking Age in Estonia. Tartu (Tartu University Press).
10.26530/OAPEN_423944 Google Scholar
- Tvauri, A. 2014. The Impact of the Climate Catastrophe of 536–537AD in Estonia and Neighbouring Areas. Estonian Journal of Archaeology 18. 30–56.
- Widgren, M. 2013. Climate and Causation in the Swedish Iron Age. Learning from the Present to Understand the Past. Geografisk Tidsskrift 112. 126–34.
- Wheeler, M. 1935. London and the Saxons. London (London Museum).
- Wheeler, M. 1956. The First Towns? Antiquity 30. 132–36.
- Wickham, C. 2005. Framing the Early Middle Ages. Europe and the Mediterranean, 400–800. Oxford (Oxford University Press).
10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199264490.001.0001 Google Scholar
- Woods, D. 2010. Gildas and the Mystery Cloud of 536–7. Journal of Theological Studies 61. 226–34.
- Wright, H.E. 1993. Environmental Determinism in Near Eastern Prehistory. Current Anthropology 34. 458–59.
- Zhang, D.D., H.F. Lee, C. Wang, B. Li, Q. Pei, J. Zhang & Y. An. 2011. The Causality Analysis of Climate Change and Large-Scale Human Crisis. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 108. 17296–17301.