Original Article
ARCHAEOLOGY AND THE SEARCH FOR HOMERIC ITHACA: THE CASE OF MYCENAEAN KEPHALONIA
Christina Souyoudzoglou-Haywood,
Christina Souyoudzoglou-Haywood
UCD School of Classics, University College Dublin, Belfield, Dublin 4 Ireland
Search for more papers by this authorChristina Souyoudzoglou-Haywood,
Christina Souyoudzoglou-Haywood
UCD School of Classics, University College Dublin, Belfield, Dublin 4 Ireland
Search for more papers by this authorABSTRACT
This short article on a large subject is presented as a tribute to Klavs Randsborg, because of his involvement in the 1990s with the archaeology of Kephalonia at the time of the resurgence of the debate over the identification of the island with Homeric Ithaca, to which he himself contributed some thoughts. It briefly traces the history of the controversy about the Homeric geography and topography from its origins and discusses the evidence that has made Kephalonia a contender for the homeland of Odysseus. The intention is not to offer yet another hypothesis about the location of Homeric Ithaca, but to consider and question the role of archaeology in the debate, in view of the high expectations of Homeric realists.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
- Alcock, S.E. 2002. Archaeologies of the Greek Past. Landscape, Monuments, and Memories. Cambridge (Cambridge University Press).
- Antonaccio, C.M. 1994. Contesting the Past: Hero Cult, and Epic in Early Greece. American Journal of Archaeology 98, 3. 389–410.
- Antonaccio, C.M. 1995. An Archaeology of Ancestors. Tomb Cult and Hero Cult in Early Greece. Boston & London (Rowman & Littlefield Publishers).
- Arena, E. 2015. Mycenaean Peripheries during the Palatial Age. The Case of Achaia. Hesperia 84. 1–46.
- Assmann, J. & J. Czaplicka. 1995. Collective Memory and Cultural Identity. New German Critique 65. Cultural History/Cultural Studies (Spring-Summer 1995). 125–133.
- Bennet, J. 2011. The Geography of the Mycenaean kingdoms. Duhoux & Morpurgo Davies 2011. 137–168.
- Benton, S. 1934–1935. Excavations in Ithaca III. The Cave of Polis, I. Annual of the British School at Athens 35, 45–73.
10.1017/S0068245400007383 Google Scholar
- Benton, S. 1938–1939. Excavations in Ithaca III. The Cave of Polis, II. Annual of the British School at Athens 39, 1–15.
10.1017/S0068245400012144 Google Scholar
- Bittlestone, R. 2005. Odysseus Unbound. The Search for Homer's Ithaca. Cambridge (Cambridge University Press).
- A.G. Brown, L.S. Basell & K.W. Butzer (eds.). 2011. Geoarchaeology Climate Change, and Sustainability. Special Paper 476. Boulder (The Geological Society of America).
- Buchholz, H.-G. 2009. Some Remarks Concerning the Heroon of Odysseus in Ithaca. Danielidou 2009. 127–142.
- J.B. Carter & S.P Morris (eds.). 1995. The Ages of Homer. Austin (University of Texas Press).
- Catling, H. 1987. Archaeological Reports for 1986–87. London (The Society for the Promotion of Hellenic Studies).
- Cavanagh, W. & C. Mee. 1998. A Private Place: Death in Prehistoric Greece. Jonsered (Paul Åström Förlag).
- Coldstream, J.N. 2003. Geometric Greece: 900–7000 BC 2nd edition (1st edition 1977). London & New York (Routledge).
- Coulson, W.D.E. 1991. The ‘Protogeometric’ from Polis Reconsidered. Annual of the British School at Athens 86. 42–64.
10.1017/S006824540001488X Google Scholar
- D. Danielidou (ed.) 2009. Δώρον. Τιμητικός τόμος για τον καθηγητή Σ. Ιακωβίδη. Athens (Athens Academy).
- Davis, J.L. & K.M. Lynch. 2017. Remembering and Forgetting Nestor: Pylian Pasts Pluperfect? Sherratt & Bennet 2017. 53–73.
- Dickinson, O.T.P.K. 2007. Aspects of Homeric Geography. Morris & Laffineur 2007. 233–238.
- Dickinson, O.T.P.K. 2011. The Catalogue of Ships. The Homer Encyclopedia. Finkelberg (Wiley-Blackwell).
- Diggle, J. 2005. Appendix 1. James Diggle: a Philologist Reflects. Bittlestone 2005. 505–529.
- Doerpfeld, W. 1927. Alt-Ithaca: ein Beitrag zur Homer-Frage: Studien und Ausgrabungen aus der Insel Leukas-Ithaka. Munich (R. Uhde).
- Y. Duhoux & A. Morpurgo Davies (eds.). 2011. A Companion to Linear B. Mycenaean Greek Texts and their World, Vol. 2. Louvain-la-Neuve - Walpole (Peeters).
- Eder, B. 2007. The Power of Seals: Palaces, Peripheries and Territorial Control in the Mycenaean World. Galanaki et al. 2007. 35–45.
- Feuer, B. 2011. Being Mycenaean: a View from the Periphery. American Journal of Archaeology 115, 4. 507–536.
- J.M. Folley (ed.). 1981. Oral Traditional Literature: A Festschrift for Albert Bates Lord. Columbus (Slavika Publishers).
- M. Fotiadis, R. Laffineur, Y. Lolos & A. Vlachopoulos (eds.). 2017. Hesperos. The Aegean Seen from the the West. Aegeum 41. Leuven-Liège (Peeters).
- Gaki-Papanastassiou, K., H. Maroukian, E. Karymbalis & D. Papanastassiou. 2011. Geomorphological Study and Paleogeographic Evolution of NW Kephalonia Island, concerning the Hypothesis of a Possible Location of Homeric Ithaca. Brown et al. 2011. 69–80.
- I. Galanaki, H. Tomas, Y. Galanakis & R. Laffineur (eds.). 2007. Between the Aegean and Baltic Seas. Prehistory across the Borders. Aegeum 27. Liège (University of Liège).
- C. Gallou, M. Georgiadis & G.M. Muskett (eds.). 2008. Dioskouroi. Studies presented to W.G. Cavanagh and C.B. Mee on the Anniversary of their 30-year joint contribution to Aegean Archaeology. Oxford (British Archaeological Reports).
- Gell, W. 1807. The Geography and Antiquities of Ithaca. London (Longman, Hurst, Rees & Orme).
- Goekoop, A.E.H. 1908. Ithaque la Grande. Athens (Beck & Barth).
- Goekoop-de Jongh, J. 1933. La Nesos Homerique. Groningen (Erven B. van der Kamp).
- Goekoop, C.H. 2010. Where on Earth is Ithaca. A Quest for the Homeland of Odysseus. Deft (Eburton). Translated and Revised from Cees Goekoop 1990. Op zoek naar Ithaka. Een speurtocht naar het vaderland van Odysseus. Weesp (Heurika).
- Grethlein, J. 2008. Memory and Material Objects in the Iliad and the Odyssey. Journal of Hellenic Studies 128. 27–51.
- Halbwachs, M. 1980. The Collective Memory. New York (Harper & Row Colophon Books). Translated from French: La mémoire collective (1950).
- Halbwachs, M. 1992. On Collective Memory. Chicago (University of Chicago Press). Translated from French: Les cadres sociaux de la mémoire (1952).
- Hellenic culture. 2008. Press release. http://84.205.251.166/2/g22.jsp?obj_id=15171. Accessed on 18.01.2018.
- Heurtley, W.A. 1937. H θέσις του ανακτόρου του Οδυσσέως (The Location of the Palace of Odysseus). Αρχαιολογική Εφημερίς 1937. 266–267.
- Heurtley, W.A. 1939/40. Excavations in Ithaca, 1930–35. Annual of the British School at Athens 40. 1–13.
10.1017/S0068245400004834 Google Scholar
- Hope Simpson, R. & J.F. Lazenby. 1970. The Catalogue of the Ships in Homer's Iliad. Oxford (Clarendon Press).
- Y. Kazazi (ed.). 2006. Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference for the Ancient Greek Technology. Athens (Technical Chamber of Greece).
- Kilian-Dirlmeier, I. 2005. Die Bronzeitlichen Gräber bei Nidri auf Leukas. Mainz (Verlag des Römisch-Germanischen Zentralmuseums).
- Knauss, J. 2006. Observations and Considerations concerning Mycenaean Underground Well-houses or Spring-chambers, especially at Mycenae, Tiryns and Ithaka. Kazazi 2006. 3–18.
- Kolonas, L. 1992. Νομός Κεφαλληνίας. Τζαννάτα Πόρου. Αρχαιολογικόν Δελτίον 47, B1. 154–157.
- Kolonas, L. 1993. Tζαννάτα. Αρχαιολογικόν Δελτίον 48, B1. 149–150.
- Kolonas, L. 1994. Πόρος Κεφαλονιάς. Patras.
- Kolonas, L. 2007. O θολωτός τάφος Τζαννάτων Πόρου Κεφαλληνίας και οι θολωτοί τάφοι της ηπειρωτικής Ελλάδος (The Tholos Tomb of Tzanata at Poros, Kephalonia, and the Tholos Tombs of Mainland Greece). Συνέδριο για τα γράμματα, την ιστορία και την λαογραφία της περιοχής των Πρόννων 8-11 Σεπτ. 2005, Πόρος. Πρακτικά.. Thessaloniki (University Studio Press). 329–369.
- Kontorli-Papadopoulou. L. 2001. Αναζητώντας την Ομηρική Ιθάκη: Πρόσφατες Ανασκαφές (Searching for Homeric Ithaca: Recent Archaeological Excavations). Eranos. Proceedings of the 9th International Symposium on the Odyssey. Ithaca 2001. Ithaca (Centre of Odyssean Studies). 317–330.
- Kontorli-Papadopoulou. L. 2014–15. Ανασκάπτοντας την Ομηρική Ιθάκη. Αποτελέσματα ανασκαφικού-ερευνητικού προγράμματος του Πανεπιστημίου Ιωαννίνων στη βόρεια Ιθάκη (Excavating Homeric Ithaca. Results of the Excavation-Research Programme of the University of Ioannina in Northern Ithaki). Επιστημονική επετηρίδα του τμήματος Ιστορίας και Αρχαιολογίας Πανεπιστημίου Ιωαννίνων. Δωδώνη. Vol. 43–44. Ioannina. 467–504.
- Kountouri, E. 2016. O Θολωτός τάφος στη θέση Αμβλιανός Άμφισας (The tholos tomb at Amvlianos, Amphissa. The first data). www.archaeologia.gr.Blog/2016/111/18. Accessed on 10.02.2018.
- Leake, W.M. 1835. Travels in Northern Greece. Vol. 3. London (J. Rodwell).
- Malkin, I. 1998. The Returns of Odysseus: Colonization and Ethnicity. Berkeley and London (University of California Press).
- Mazarakis Ainian, A. 2017. Heroes of Iron Age Greece and the Homeric Epics. Sherratt & Bennet 2017. 101–115.
- MIET (Morphotiko Idryma Ethnikes Trapezes/Archeio Chartografias tou Ellenikou Kosmou) 2007. To Ιόνιο πέλαγος. Χαρτογραφία και ιστορία 6ος – 18ος Αιώνας (The Ionian Sea. Chartography and History 16th-18th Centuries). Athens.
- Morgan, C. 1988. Corinth, the Corinthian Gulf and Western Greece during the Eighth Century BC. Annual of the British School at Athens 83. 331–338.
10.1017/S0068245400020785 Google Scholar
- S.P. Morris & R.A. Laffineur (eds.). 2007. EPOS. Reconsidering Greek Epic and Aegean Bronze Age Archaeology. Aegaeum 28. Liège (University of Liège).
- Moschos, I. 2007. H περιοχή των Πρόννων και η ανατολική ακτήτης Κεφαλονιάς πριν από την ιστορία (The Region of Pronnoi and the Eastern Coast of Kephalonia before History). Συνέδριο για τα γράμματα, την ιστορία και την λαογραφία της περιοχής των Πρόννων 8-11 Σεπτ. 2005, Πόρος. Πρακτικά. Thessaloniki (University Studio Press). 228–316.
- Mountjoy, P.A. 1999. Regional Decorated Pottery. Vol 2. Rahden/Westf. (Leidorf).
- J. Murray (ed.). 1854. Handbook for Travellers in Greece. Describing the Ionian Islands, the Kingdom of Greece, the Islands of the Aegean Sea, with Albania, Thessaly, and Macedonia. London (John Murr).
- Nagy, G. 1979. The Best of the Achaeans: Concepts of the Hero in Ancient Greek Poetry. Baltimore (Johns Hopkins University Press).
- Nagy, G. 1981. An Evolutionary Model for the Text Fixation of Homeric Epos. Folley 1981. 390–393.
- Nagy, G. 1995. An Evolutionary Model for the Making of Homeric Poetry: Comparative Perspectives. Carter & Morris 1995. 163–179.
- Nora, P. 1989. Between Memory and History: Les lieux de mémoire. Representations 26. Special Issue: Memory and Counter-Memory (Spring 1989). 7–24.
10.2307/2928520 Google Scholar
- Paizis-Danias, D.I. 2007. Homer's Ithaca on Cephallenia? Facts and Fancies in the History of an Idea. Ithaca (Ithacan friends of Homer Association “ΕΥΧΗΝ ΟΔΥΣΣΕΙ”).
- Papadopoulos, T. 2016. The Heroon of Odysseus in Ithaca Reconsidered. http://users.uoi.gr/gramisar/pdfs_docs/anaskafes_erevnes/ithaka/The_Heroon_of_Odysseus_at_Ithaca_Reconsidered_P-P.pdf Accessed on 05.03.2018.
- Papadopoulos, T. 2017. Mycenaean Citadels of Western Greece: Architecture, Purpose and their Intricate Role in the Local Communities and their Relations with the West. Fotiadis et al. 2017. 419–430.
- Petrakis, V. 2006. History versus the Homeric Iliad: a View from the Ionian Islands. The Classical World 99, 4. 371–396.
- Putman Cramer, H. & G. Metaxas. 2000. Ομηρική Ιθάκη (Homeric Ithaca). Athens (Kaktos).
- Randsborg, K. 2002. Kephallénia. Archaeology and History. The Ancient Cities. Acta Archaeologica 73. Vols. 1 & 2. Copenhagen (Blackwell Munksgaard).
- Schliemann, H. 1869. Ithaka, der Peloponnes und Troja. Leipzig (Giesecke & Devrient).
- Sherratt, E.S. 1990. ‘Reading the Texts': Archaeology and the Homeric Question. Antiquity 84. 807–824.
- S. Sherratt & J. Bennet (eds.). 2017. Archaeology and Homeric Epic. Sheffield Studies in Aegean Archaeology. Oxford and Philadelphia (Oxbow).
- Snodgrass, A.M. 1974. An historical Homeric society? Journal of Hellenic Studies 94. 114–125.
10.2307/630424 Google Scholar
- Sotiriou, A. 2000. Nεώτερα στοιχεία της αρχαίας μνημειακής τοπογραφίας της νήσου Κεφαλονιάς (New Data about the Ancient Topography of the Island of Kephalonia). Proceedings of the 6th International Panaionian Conference, Zakynthos 23–27 September 1997. Vol. A. Thessaloniki. 105–123.
- Sotiriou, A., E. Papafloratou, I. Voskos, E. Tzane 2018. Mυκηναική Κεφαλονιά: οι πρόσφατες ανασκαφικές έρευνες ( Mycenaean Kephalonia: the Latest Archaeological Investigations). To Aρχαιολογικό έργο στην βορειο-δυτική Ελλάδα και τα νησιά του Ιονίου. Ιωάννινα, 10–13 Δεκεμβρίου 2014. Πρακτικά 757–766. Ioannina.
- Souyoudzoglou-Haywood, C. 1999. The Ionian Islands in the Bronze Age and Early Iron Age. Liverpool (Liverpool University Press).
- Souyoudzoglou-Haywood, C. 2008. Interpreting the Bronze Age Landscape of Kephalonia. A (Preliminary) View from the Livatho Valley Survey. Gallou et al. 2008. 237–251.
- Souyoudzoglou-Haywood, C. (forthcoming). Reuse and Cult at the Mycenaean Tombs of Kephalonia in the Ancient Historical Periods. Πρακτικά του ΙΑ’ Διεθνού ς Πανιό νιου Συνεδρί ου. Αργοστόλι, 21–25 Μαΐ ου 2018. Εταιρεία Κεφαλληνιακών Ιστορικών Ερευνών.
- Souyoudzoglou-Haywood, C, A. Sotiriou & E. Papafloratou. 2017. Living at the edge. SW Kephalonia: an Island Region of the Western Aegean World in the Post-Palatial Period. Fotiadis et al. 2017. 383–394.
- Souyoudzoglou-Haywood, C, A. Sotiriou & E. Papafloratou (in print). The pottery from the Mycenaean site at Palia Stane-Prospholeika, Kephalonia: Some preliminary remarks. To αρχαιολογικό έργο στην βορειο-δυτική Ελλάδα και τα νησιά του Ιονίου. Ιωάννινα, 23–26 Νοεμβρίου 2017. Πρακτικά. Ioannina.
- Symeonoglou, S. 1986. H Ομηρική γεωγραφία της Ιθάκης. Μύθος και ιστορία (The Homeric Geography of Ithaca. Myth and history). Proceedings of the 4th International Symposium on the Odyssey, 9–15 September 1984. Ithaca (Centre of Odyssean Studies). 91–110.
- Tomlinson, R.A. 1996. Archaeology in Greece. Archaeological Reports for 1995–98. 1–47.
- Vasilakis, A. 2011. Archaiologia.gr.blog 28/11/2011. Accessed on 05.03.2018.
- Vikatou, O. 2017. Meganissi Lafkada. A New Site of the End of the Mycenaean Era. Fotiadis et al. 2017. 369–382.
- Vollgraff, C. 1905. Fouilles d’ Ithaque. Bulletin de Correspondance Hellénique 29. 145–168.
10.3406/bch.1905.3299 Google Scholar
- Waterhouse, H. 1996. From Ithaca to the Odyssey. Annual of the British School at Athens 91. 301–318.
10.1017/S0068245400016518 Google Scholar
- Wardle, K. A. 1972. The Greek Bronze Age West of the Pindus: a Study of the Period ca. 3000–1000 BC in Epirus, Aitoloakarnania, the Ionian Islands, Adriatic and Balkan Regions. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of London.
