SPECIAL ISSUE
A Theory of Capitalist Slavery
John Clegg,
John Clegg
Collegiate Assistant Professor in the Social Sciences and Harper-Schmidt Fellow, University of ChicagoSearch for more papers by this authorJohn Clegg,
John Clegg
Collegiate Assistant Professor in the Social Sciences and Harper-Schmidt Fellow, University of ChicagoSearch for more papers by this authorAbstract
The relationship between slavery and capitalism has become a renewed topic of debate, yet scholars have not been able to agree on a definition of capitalism. In this article I first clear up some misconceptions and situate the debate in the Marxian tradition from which it arose. I argue that while non-Marxian accounts of capitalism fail to explain the key social transformations that have accompanied the rise of capitalism globally, Marxian accounts have failed to comprehend similar transformations that occurred on American slave plantations in the 19th century. I then present a general model of capitalism, building on earlier work by Brenner and Wood, that both incorporates and explains the distinctive dynamics of capitalist slavery in the antebellum South.
REFERENCES
- Aitken, H. (1971). Did Slavery Pay?: Readings in the Economics of Black Slavery in the United States. Houghton Mifflin.
- Alston, L. J., & Kauffman, K. D. (2001). Competition and the compensation of sharecroppers by race: A view from plantations in the early twentieth century. Ex- Plorations in Economic History, 38(1), 181–194.
- Anderson, R., & Gallman, R. (1977). Slaves as fixed capital: Slave labor and southern economic development. The Journal of American History, 64(1), 24–46.
- Anievas, A., & Nisancioglu, K. (2014). The poverty of political Marxism. International Socialist Review, 94, 1–25.
- Ashworth, J. (2011). Towards a bourgeois revolution? Explaining the American civil war. Historical Materialism, 19(4), 45–57.
- Atack, J., & Bateman, F. (1999). Nineteenth-century US industrial development through the eyes of the census of manufactures. Historical Methods, 32(4), 177.
- Balleisen, E. J. (2001). Navigating Failure: Bankruptcy and Commercial Society in Antebellum America. University of North Carolina Press.
- Baptist, E. (2014). The half has never been told: Slavery and the making of American capitalism. New York: Basic books.
- Bateman, F., & Weiss, T. (1981). A Deplorable Scarcity: The Failure of Industrialization in the Slave Economy. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.
- Beckert, S. (2015). Empire of cotton: A global history. Vintage.
- Beckert, S., Burgin, A., Hudson, P. J., Hyman, L., Lamoreaux, N., Marler, S., & Mihm, S. (2014). Interchange: The history of capitalism. Journal of American History, 101(2), 503–536.
- Bertocchi, G., & Dimico, A. (2012). The racial gap in education and the legacy of slavery. Journal of Comparative Economics, 40(4), 581–595.
- Blackburn, R. (2011). The American Crucible: Slavery, Emancipation and Human Rights. London: Verso.
- Bodenhorn, H., & Rockoff, H. (1992). Regional interest rates in antebellum America. In Goldin, C. and Rockoff, (eds.) Strategic Factors in Nineteenth Century American Economic History: A Volume to Honor Robert W. Fogel. University of Chicago Press.
- Brandon, P. (2017). From Williams’s thesis to Williams thesis: An anti-colonial Trajectory. International Review of Social History, 62(2), 305–327.
- Brenner, R. (1976). Agrarian class structure and economic development in pre-industrial Europe. Past & Present, 70, 30–75.
10.1093/past/70.1.30 Google Scholar
- Brenner, R. (1977). The origins of capitalist development: A critique of neo-Smithian Marx- ism. New Left Review I, 104.
- Brenner, R. (1982). The agrarian roots of European capitalism. Past & Present, 16–113.
- Brenner, R. (2007). Property and Progress: Where Adam Smith Went Wrong, in C. Wickham (Ed) Marxist History-Writing for the Twenty-First Century. Oxford University Press, 49–111.
10.5871/bacad/9780197264034.003.0004 Google Scholar
- Broadberry, S., Campbell, B., & Van Leeuwen, B. (2011). The Sectoral Distribution of the Labour Force and Labour Productivity in Britain, 1381–1851. Unpublished paper presented at HI-POD Workshop Quantifying long run economic development, University of Warwick in Venice, Palazzo Pesaro Papafava.
- Carter, S. B., Gartner, S. S., Haines, M. R., Olmstead, A. L., Sutch, R., & Wright, G.. (2006). Historical Statistics of the United States Millennial Edition Online. New York: Cambridge University Press.
- Chibber, V. (2017). Rescuing class from the cultural turn Catalyst, 1(1).
- Clegg, J. J. (2015). Capitalism and slavery. Critical Historical Studies, 2(2), 281–304.
- Clegg, J. J. (2017). Credit market discipline and capitalist slavery in antebellum South Carolina. Social Science History, 42(2), 343–376.
- Clegg, J. J., & Foley, D. (2018). A classical-Marxian model of antebellum slavery. Cambridge Journal of Economics, 64(1), 24.
- Coclanis, P. A. (2018). Slavery, Capitalism, and the Problem of Misprision. Journal of American Studies, 52(3), e46.
- Cohen, G. (2000). Karl Marx’s Theory of History: A Defence. Oxford University Press.
- Coleman, A., & Hutchinson, W. (2006). Determinants of Slave Prices: Louisiana, 1725 to 1820. Vanderbilt University Department of Economics Working Papers 0624, Vanderbilt University Department of Economics.
- Conrad, A., & Meyer, J. (1958). The economics of slavery in the ante bellum south. The Journal of Political Economy, 66(2), 95–130.
- CORE. (2017). The Economy: Economics for a Changing World. Oxford University Press.
- David, P. A., Gutman, H. G., Sutch, R., Temin, P., & Wright, G. (1976). Reckoning with slavery: a critical study in the quantitative history of American Negro slavery. New York: Oxford University Press.
- DeCanio, S. J. (1974). Agriculture in the Postbellum South: The Economics of Production and Supply. Cambridge: M.I.T. Press.
- Delfino, S., & Gillespie, M. (2008). Technology, innovation, and Southern industrializa- tion: from the antebellum era to the computer age. University of Missouri.
- Desmond, M. (2019). In order to understand the brutality of American capitalism, you have to start on the plantation. The New York Times Magazine: 1619 Project.
- Deyle, S. (2005). Carry Me Back: The Domestic Slave Trade in American Life. Oxford University Press.
- Dobb, M. (1963). Studies in the Development of Capitalism. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
- Du Bois, W. E. B. (1935). Black Reconstruction. An essay toward a history of the part which black folk played in the attempt to reconstruct democracy in America, 1860–1880. New York: Russel & Russel.
- Egerton, D. R. (1996). Markets without a market revolution: Southern planters and capitalism. Journal of the Early Republic, 16(2), 207–221.
10.2307/3124246 Google Scholar
- Einhorn, R. L. (2015). Slavery. Enterprise and Society, 9(03), 491–506.
10.1017/S1467222700007291 Google Scholar
- Eisner, G. (1961). Jamaica 1830–1930: A Study in Economic Growth. Manchester University Press.
- Elster, J. (1983). Exploitation, Freedom, and Justice. Nomos, 26, 277–304.
- Engerman, S. L. (1967). The effects of slavery upon the southern economy: A review of the recent debate. Explorations in Entrepreneurial History, 4(2), 71–97.
- Engerman, S. L. (1973). Some considerations relating to property rights in man. The Journal of Economic History, 33(1), 43–65.
- Engerman, S. L. (2001). One Kind of Freedom: A comparative perspective. Explorations in Economic History.
- Fields, B. J. (1985). The Advent of Capitalist Agriculture: the New South in a Bourgeois World, in T. Glymph, & J. J. Kushma (Eds) Essays on the Postbellum Southern Economy. A & M University Press.
- Fleischman, R. K., & Tyson, T. N. (2004). Accounting in service to racism: Monetizing slave property in the antebellum south. Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 15(3), 376–399.
10.1016/S1045-2354(03)00102-3 Google Scholar
- Fleisig, H. (1976). Slavery, the supply of agricultural labor, and the industrialization of the south. The Journal of Economic History, 36(3), 572–597.
- Fogel, R. W. (1977). Explaining the relative efficiency of slave agriculture in the antebellum south. The American Economic Review, 67(3), 275–296.
- Fogel, R. W. (2006). The Slavery Debates, 1952–1990: A Retrospective. Walter Lynwood Fleming Lectures in Southern History. Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press.
- Fogel, R. W., & Engerman, S. L. (1975). Time on the Cross: The Economics of American Negro Slavery. Vol. I & II. New York: W. W. Norton & Company.
- Follett, R. (2000). Slavery and plantation capitalism in Louisiana’s sugar country. American Nineteenth Century History, 1(3), 1–27.
10.1080/14664650008567022 Google Scholar
- Foner, P. S. (1941). Business & slavery: the New York merchants & the irrepressible conflict. University of North Carolina Press.
- Foust, J. D., & Swan, D. E. (1970). Productivity and profitability of antebellum slave labor: A micro-approach. Agricultural History, 44(1), 39–62.
- Gallman, R. E. (1992). “American economic growth before the Civil War: The testimony of the capital stock estimates”. In Gallman and Wallis (eds.) American Economic Growth and Standards of Living before the Civil War. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. 79–120.
- Genovese, E. D. (1965). The Political Economy of Slavery: Studies in the Economy & Society of the Slave South. New York: Pantheon Books.
- Genovese, E. D. (1971). In Red and Black: Marxian Explorations in Southern and Afro-American History. New York: Vintage Books.
- Genovese, E. D., & Fox-Genovese, E. (1983). Fruits of Merchant Capital: Slavery and Bourgeois Property in the Rise and Expansion of Capitalism. New York: Oxford University Press.
- Gray, L. (1933). History of Agriculture in the Southern United States to 1860. Washington.
- Green, G. D. (1972). Finance and economic development in the Old South: Louisiana banking, 1804–1861. Stanford, Calif: Stanford University Press.
- Hacker, L. M. (1940). The Triumph of American Capitalism: The Development of Forces in American History to the End of the Nineteenth Century. New York: Simon Schuste.
- Hahn, S. (1983). Capitalists All! Reviews in American History, 11(2), 219–225.
10.2307/2702146 Google Scholar
- Harvey, D. (2010). A Companion to Marx’s Capital. London: Verso.
- Heier, J. R. (2010). Accounting for the business of suffering: A study of the antebellum Richmond, Virginia, slave trade. Abacus, 46(1), 60–83.
- Himmel, R., & Novack, G. E. (1966). Marxist Essays in American History. New York: Merit Publishers.
- Hudson, P. J. (2016). Racial Capitalism and the Dark Proletariat. Boston Review.
- Huston, J. L. (1999). Property rights in slavery and the coming of the civil war. The Journal of Southern History, 65(2), 249–286.
- Huston, J. L. (2019). Slavery, capitalism, and the interpretations of the antebellum United States: The problem of definition. Civil War History, 65(2), 119–156.
- James, C. L. R. (1938). The Black Jacobins: Toussaint L’Ouverture and the San Domingo Revolution. Secker & Warburg.
- James, C. L. R. (1943). The West Indies in Review: Recent Developments in the Caribbean Colonies. The New International IX (6 (Whole No. 76)): 191–184.
- James, C. (1939). Stalinism and negro history. CLR James and Revolutionary Marxism: Selected Writings by CLR James, New Jersey: Humanities Press (1994), 87–179.
- Johnson, W. (2004). The pedestal and the veil: Rethinking the capitalism/slavery Question. Journal of the Early Republic, 24(2), 299–308.
- Johnson, W. (2001). Soul by Soul: Life inside the Antebellum Slave Market. Harvard University Press.
- Johnson, W. (2013). River of Dark Dreams. Harvard University Press.
10.2307/j.ctvjsf5q7 Google Scholar
- Kilbourne, R. (1995). Debt, Investment, Slaves: Credit Relations in East Feliciana Parish, Louisiana, 1825–1885. University of Alabama Press.
- Kilbourne, R. (2006). Slave agriculture and financial markets in antebellum America: the Bank of the United States in Mississippi, 1831–1852. Pickering & Chatto Publishers.
- Klein, H. S., & Luna, F. V. (2009). Slavery in Brazil. Cambridge University Press.
10.1017/CBO9780511815393 Google Scholar
- Kolchin, P. (1993). American Slavery, 1619–1877. New York: Hill/Wang.
- Lakwete, A. (2005). Inventing the cotton gin: machine and myth in Antebellum America. Johns Hopkins University Press.
- Lebergott, S. (2009). The demand for land: The United States, 1820–1860. The Journal of Economic History, 45, 181.
- Levy, J. (2012). The Mortgage Worked the Hardest: The Fate of Landed Independence in Nineteenth Century America, in M. Zakim, & G. Kornblith (Eds) Capitalism Takes Command: The Social Transformation of Nineteenth-century America. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
- Linden, M. v. d., & Roth, K. H. (2013). Results and Prospects, in M. v. D. Linden, & K. H. Roth (Eds) Beyond Marx: Theorising the Global Labour Relations of the Twenty-First Century. Leiden: Brill.
- Lindert, P., & Williamson, J. (2016). Unequal Gains: American Growth and Inequality since 1700. The Princeton Economic History of the Western World. Princeton University Press.
10.1515/9781400880348 Google Scholar
- Majewski, J. (2011). Modernizing a slave economy: the economic vision of the Confederate Nation. UNC Press.
- Mandle, J. R. (1972). The plantation economy: An essay in definition. Science & Society, 36(1), 49–62.
- Martin, B. (2010). Slavery’s invisible engine: Mortgaging human property. The Journal of Southern History, 76(4), 817–866.
- Marx, K. (1913). The poverty of philosophy. CH Kerr & Company.
- Marx, K. (1935). Wage-labour and capital & Value, price, and profit. New York: International Publishers.
- Marx, K. (1968). Theories of Surplus-Value. Moscow: Progress Publishers.
- Marx, K. (1971). Capital. Vol. 1. London: Penguin.
- Marx, K. (1973). Grundrisse: Foundations of the Critique of Political Economy. New York: Vintage Books.
- Marx, K. (1981). Capital. Vol. 3. London: Pelican Books.
- Marx, K. (2010). Economic manuscript of 1861–63. Vol. 30. Marx and Engels Collected Works. London: Lawrence/Wishart.
- McCloskey, D. N. (2018). Slavery did not make America rich. Reason.
- McCurry, S. (2017). Plunder of black life. Times Literary Supplement.
- Moes, J. (1961). The absorption of Capital in Slave Labor in the ante-bellum south and economic growth. The American Journal of Economics and Sociology, 20(5), 535–541.
- Morris, T. D. (1999). Southern slavery and the law, 1619–1860. University of North Carolina Press.
- Murray, J. E., Olmstead, A. L., Logan, T. D., Pritchett, J. B., & Rousseau, P. L. (2015). Reviews of the half has never been told: Slavery and the making of American capitalism, by Edward E. Baptist. Journal of Economic History, 75, 919–931.
- Murray, P. (2016). The Mismeasure of Wealth: Essays on Marx and Social Form. Leiden: Brill.
10.1163/9789004326071 Google Scholar
- Naidu, S., & Dittmar, J. (2012). Peculiar Institutions: Slavery and Labor Market Frictions in the USA. Unpublished manuscript.
- Neal, L., & Williamson, J. G. (2014). The Cambridge History of Capitalism: Volume 1, The Rise of Capitalism: From Ancient Origins to 1848. Cambridge University Press.
- Neptune, H. (2019). Throwin’ Scholarly Shade: Eric Williams in the New Histories of Capitalism and Slavery. Journal of the Early Republic, 39.
- Oakes, J. (1983). The Ruling Race: A History of American Slaveholders. New York: Vintage Books.
- Oakes, J. (2016). Capitalism and slavery and the civil war. International Labor and Working-Class History, 89, 195–220.
- Olmstead, A. L., & Rhode, P. W. (2010). “Productivity Growth and the Regional Dynamics of Antebellum Southern Development”: NBER Working Papers 16494, National Burea of Economic Research, Inc..
- Olmstead, A. L., & Rhode, P. W. (2018). Cotton, slavery, and the new history of capitalism. Explorations in Economic History, 67, 1–17.
- Parker, W. N., & Klein, J. L. V. (1966). Productivity Growth in Grain Production in the United States, 1840–60 and 1900–10, in Output, Employment, and Productivity in the United States after, Dorothy S. Brady, 523–582. NBER.
- Patterson, O. (1977). “Slavery.” Annual Review of Sociology 3, -:407–449.
- Patterson, O. (1979). On slavery and slave formations. New Left Review, 117, 31–67.
- Phillips, U. B. (1910). The decadence of the plantation system. The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 35(1), 37–41.
10.1177/000271621003500105 Google Scholar
- Post, C. (1982). The American road to capitalism. New Left Review, 133, 30–51.
- Post, C. (2011). The American Road to Capitalism: Studies in Class-Structure, Economic Development, and Political Conflict, 1620–1877. Leiden: Brill.
10.1163/ej.9789004201040.i-298 Google Scholar
- Post, C. (2017). Slavery and the new history of capitalism. Catalyst, 1(1).
- Post, C. (2018). Capitalist slavery in the great Caribbean? Almanack, 19, 321–330.
10.1590/2236-463320181908 Google Scholar
- Ralph, M. (2012). “ Life. . . in the midst of death”: Notes on the relationship between slave insurance, life insurance and disability. Disability Studies Quarterly, 32(3).
10.18061/dsq.v32i3.3267 Google Scholar
- Ransom, R. L., & Sutch, R. (1982). “The long run implications of capital absorption in slave labor.”
- Ransom, R. L., & Sutch, R. (2001). One kind of freedom: Reconsidered (and Turbo charged). Explorations in Economic History, 38(1), 6–39.
- Ransom, R., & Sutch, R. (1977). One Kind of Freedom: The Economic Consequences of Emancipation. Cambridge University Press.
- Rockman, S. (2014). What makes the history of capitalism newsworthy? Journal of the Early Republic, 34, 439–466.
- S. Rockman, & S. Beckert, (Eds.) (2016). Slavery’s Capitalism: A New History of American Economic Development. University of Pennsylvania Press.
- Roediger, D. R. (2010). A white intellectual among thinking black intellectuals: George Rawick and the settings of genius. South Atlantic Quarterly, 109(2), 225–247.
- Rosenbloom, J. L. (2002). Looking for work, searching for workers: American labor markets during industrialization. Cambridge University Press.
10.1017/CBO9780511549793 Google Scholar
- Rosenthal, C. (2018). Accounting for slavery: Masters and management. Harvard University Press.
10.4159/9780674988590 Google Scholar
- Schermerhorn, C. (2015). The business of slavery and the rise of American capitalism, 1815–1860. Yale University Press.
10.12987/yale/9780300192001.001.0001 Google Scholar
- Schluter, H. (1913). Lincoln, Labor and Slavery: A Chapter from the Social History of America. New York: Socialist literature co.
- Schweikart, L. (1987). Southern banks and economic growth in the antebellum period: A reassessment. The Journal of Southern History, 53(1), 19–36.
- Shugg, R. W. (1937). Survival of the plantation system in Louisiana. The Journal of Southern History, 3(3), 311.
10.2307/2191238 Google Scholar
- Sloan, H. E. (2001). Principle and interest: Thomas Jefferson and the problem of debt. University of Virginia Press.
- Stiglitz, J. E. (1974). Incentives and risk sharing in sharecropping. The Review of Economic Studies, 41(2), 219.
- Stokes, M., & Conway, S. (1996). The Market Revolution in America: Social, Political, and Religious Expressions, 1800–1880. University Press of Virginia.
- Sutch, R. (1965). The profitability of ante bellum slavery: Revisited. Southern Economic Journal, 31(4), 365–377.
- Sutch, R. C. (2018). The Economics of African American Slavery: The Cliometrics Debate. National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper Series: 1–67.
- Tadman, M. (1996). Speculators and Slaves: Masters, Traders, and Slaves in the Old South. University of Wisconsin Press.
- Tomich, D. W. (2016). Slavery in the Circuit of Sugar: Martinique and the World-Economy, 1830–1848. SUNY Press.
- Towne, M., & Rasmussen, W. (1960). Farm gross product and gross investment in the nineteenth century, in The Conference on Research in Income and Wealth (Ed) Trends in the American Economy in the Nineteenth Century, p. 255–316. Princeton University Press.
- U.S.D.A. (1868). Report of the Commisioner of Agriculture for the Year 1867. Washington DC: Government Printing Office.
- U.S.D.A. (1927). Prices of Farm Products Received by Producers. USDA Statistical Bulletin.
- Vedder, R. K. (1975). The slave exploitation (expropriation) rate. Explorations in Economic History, 12(4), 453–457.
- Vedder, R. K., Gallaway, L. E., & Klingaman, D. (1978). Discrimination and Exploitation in antebellum American cotton textile manufacturing. Research in Economic History, 3, 217–262.
- Weber, M. (2002). The Protestant Ethic and the “Spirit” of Capitalism and Other Writings. Penguin Books.
- Weiss, T. (1992). US Labor Force Estimates and Economic Growth, 1800–1860, in J. J. Wallis, & R. E. Gallman American Economic Growth and Standards of Living before the Civil War, 19–78. University of Chicago Press.
- Williams, E. (1944). Capitalism and Slavery. UNC Press.
- Wood, E. (2002). The Origin of Capitalism: A Longer View. Verso Books.
- Woodman, H. D. (1968). King Cotton and his retainers: Financing and marketing the cotton crop of the South, 1800–1925. Lexington: University of Kentucky Press.
- Wright, G. (1978). The Political Economy of the Cotton South: Households, Markets, and Wealth in the Nineteenth Century. New York: W. W. Norton & Company.
- Wright, G. (1986). Old South, new South: Revolutions in the southern economy since the Civil War. New York: Basic Books.
- Wright, G. (2013). Slavery and American Economic Development. Baton Rouge: LSU Press.
- Wright, G. (Forthcoming). Slavery and Anglo-American Capitalism Revisited. The Economic History Review.
- Zimmerman, A. (2016). Introduction, in A. Zimmerman (Ed) The Civil War in the United States. New York: International Publishers.
Citing Literature
