A Dryland Cropping Revolution? Linking an Emerging Soil Health Paradigm with Shifting Social Fields among Wheat Growers of the High Plains†
Corresponding Author
Steven T. Rosenzweig
Department of Soil and Crop Sciences, Colorado State University
General Mills
Correspondence
Steven T. Rosenzweig, General Mills, 9000 Plymouth Ave N, Golden Valley, MN 55427. E-mail: steven.t.rosenzweig@gmail.com
Search for more papers by this authorMichael S. Carolan
Department of Sociology, Colorado State University
Search for more papers by this authorMeagan E. Schipanski
Department of Soil and Crop Sciences, Colorado State University
Search for more papers by this authorCorresponding Author
Steven T. Rosenzweig
Department of Soil and Crop Sciences, Colorado State University
General Mills
Correspondence
Steven T. Rosenzweig, General Mills, 9000 Plymouth Ave N, Golden Valley, MN 55427. E-mail: steven.t.rosenzweig@gmail.com
Search for more papers by this authorMichael S. Carolan
Department of Sociology, Colorado State University
Search for more papers by this authorMeagan E. Schipanski
Department of Soil and Crop Sciences, Colorado State University
Search for more papers by this authorAbstract
Once reliant on year-long periods of unvegetated fallow, dryland farmers are reaping environmental and economic benefits by replacing fallow with a crop, a practice called cropping system intensification. However, in the U.S. High Plains, transitions to intensified cropping systems have been slow relative to other regions, and cropping systems have stratified into varying degrees of intensity. Prior attempts to explain the wave of cropping system intensification have largely focused on simple economic rationales, and thus we lack a critical understanding of the social dynamics underlying the revolution in semi-arid cropping systems. We examined the motivations, perceptions, and social interactions of dryland farmers that practice different levels of cropping system intensity in Colorado and Nebraska. Building on Carolan's application of Bourdieusian social fields to agriculture, we identify overlapping fields expressed among interviewees. While these fields are reflected in farms' different degrees of intensification, they can be used to help identify and locate farmers associated with the emerging soil health (or regenerative agriculture) movement. The paper concludes by identifying strategies for change, some which would serve to reshape social fields, and others which leverage existing social positions and relationships to enable farmers to overcome the barriers constraining cropping system intensification.
References
- Aiken, Robert M., Daniel M. O'Brien, Brian L. Olson, and Leigh Murray. 2013. “Replacing Fallow with Continuous Cropping Reduces Crop Water Productivity of Semiarid Wheat.” Agronomy Journal 105(1): 199–207.
- Anderson, Benedict. 1983. Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism. New York, NY: Verso Books.
- Anderson, Jock R. and John L. Dillon. 1992. Risk Analysis in Dryland Farming Systems. Rome, Italy: Food & Agriculture Organization.
- Appadurai, Arjun. 2013. The Future as Cultural Fact: Essays on the Global Condition. London, England: Verso.
- Basche, Andrea D. and Gabrielle E. Roesch-McNally. 2017. “Research Topics to Scale Up Cover Crop Use: Reflections from Innovative Iowa Farmers.” Journal of Soil and Water Conservation 72(3): 59A–63A.
- Blesh, Jennifer and Steven A. Wolf. 2014. “Transitions to Agroecological Farming Systems in the Mississippi River Basin: Toward an Integrated Socioecological Analysis.” Agriculture and Human Values 31(4): 621–35.
- Bourdieu, Pierre. 1977. Outline of a Theory of Practice. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
10.1017/CBO9780511812507 Google Scholar
- Bourdieu, Pierre. 1990. The Logic of Practice. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
10.1515/9781503621749 Google Scholar
- Bowman, Maria and David Zilberman. 2013. “Economic Factors Affecting Diversified Farming Systems.” Ecology and Society 18(1): 33.
- Burton, Rob J. F. 2004. “Seeing through the ‘Good Farmer's’ Eyes: Towards Developing an Understanding of the Social Symbolic Value of ‘Productivist’ Behaviour.” Sociologia Ruralis 44(2): 195–215.
- Carlisle, Liz. 2016. “Factors Influencing Farmer Adoption of Soil Health Practices in the United States: A Narrative Review.” Agroecology and Sustainable Food Systems 40(6): 583–613.
- Carolan, Michael S. 2005. “Barriers to the Adoption of Sustainable Agriculture on Rented Land: An Examination of Contesting Social Fields.” Rural Sociology 70(3): 387–413.
- Carolan, Michael S. 2006a. “Do You See What I See? Examining the Epistemic Barriers to Sustainable Agriculture.” Rural Sociology 71(2): 232–60.
- Carolan, Michael S. 2006b. “Social Change and the Adoption and Adaptation of Knowledge Claims: Whose Truth Do You Trust in Regard to Sustainable Agriculture?” Agriculture and Human Values 23(3): 325–39.
- Carolan, Michael S. 2018. “Lands Changing Hands: Experiences of Succession and Farm (Knowledge) Acquisition among First-generation, Multigenerational, and Aspiring Farmers.” Land Use Policy 79: 179–89.
- Chouinard, Hayley H., Tobias Paterson, Philip R. Wandschneider, and Adrienne M. Ohler. 2008. “Will Farmers Trade Profits for Stewardship? Heterogeneous Motivations for Farm Practice Selection.” Land Economics 84(1): 66–82.
- Cochran, Verlan, Joan Danielson, Robert Kolberg, and Perry Miller. 2006. “Dryland Cropping in the Canadian Prairies and the US Northern Great Plains.” AGRONOMY 23(2): 293.
- Derksen, Doug A., Randy L. Anderson, Robert E. Blackshaw, and Bruce Maxwell. 2002. “Weed Dynamics and Management Strategies for Cropping Systems in the Northern Great Plains.” Agronomy Journal 94(2): 174–85.
- Dhuyvetter, Kevin C., Curtis R. Thompson, Charles A. Norwood, and Ardell D. Halvorson. 1996. “Economics of Dryland Cropping Systems in the Great Plains: A Review.” Journal of Production Agriculture 9(2): 216–22.
10.2134/jpa1996.0216 Google Scholar
- Di Falco, Salvatore and Charles Perrings. 2005. “Crop Biodiversity, Risk Management and the Implications of Agricultural Assistance.” Ecological Economics 55(4): 459–66.
- Flora, Cornelia Butler. 2018. Rural Communities: Legacy+ Change. New York, NY: Routledge.
10.4324/9780429494697 Google Scholar
- Flora, Cornelia Butler and Charles F. Curtiss. 2014. “ Social Sustainability of Cellulosic Energy Cropping Systems.” Pp. 315–33 in Cellulosic Energy Cropping Systems, edited by Douglas L. Karlen. Chichester, England: Wiley.
10.1002/9781118676332.ch17 Google Scholar
- Frey, Serita D., Edward T. Elliott, and Keith Paustian. 1999. “Bacterial and Fungal Abundance and Biomass in Conventional and No-tillage Agroecosystems Along Two Climatic Gradients.” Soil Biology and Biochemistry 31(4): 573–85.
- Gilbert, Nigel. 1995. Researching Social Life. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
- Glaser, Barney and Anselm Strauss. 1967. The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research. Chicago, IL: Aldine.
- Gould, Brian W., William E. Saupe, and Richard M. Klemme.1989. “Conservation Tillage: The Role of Farm and Operator Characteristics and the Perception of Soil Erosion.” Land Economics 65(2): 167–82.
- Greb, B. W. 1979. Reducing Drought Effects on Croplands in the West-central Great Plains. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Agriculture.
- Grothmann, Torsten and Anthony Patt. 2005. “Adaptive Capacity and Human Cognition: The Process of Individual Adaptation to Climate Change.” Global Environmental Change 15(3): 199–213.
- Hansen, Neil C., Brett L. Allen, R. Louis Baumhardt, and Drew J. Lyon. 2012. “Research Achievements and Adoption of No-till, Dryland Cropping in the Semi-arid US Great Plains.” Field Crops Research 132: 196–203.
- Helms, Douglas. 1990. “Conserving the Plains: The Soil Conservation Service in the Great Plains.” Agricultural History 64(2): 58–73.
- Kaan, Dennis A. 2002. “ An Economic Evaluation of Alternative Crop Rotations Compared to Wheat-Fallow in Northeastern Colorado.” Technical Bulletin TB-02-1. Fort Collins, CO: Colorado Agricultural Experiment Station.
- Knowler, Duncan and Ben Bradshaw. 2007. “Farmers' Adoption of Conservation Agriculture: A Review and Synthesis of Recent Research.” Food Policy 32(1): 25–48.
- Lin, Brenda B. 2011. “Resilience in Agriculture through Crop Diversification: Adaptive Management for Environmental Change.” BioScience 61(3): 183–93.
- Lyon, Drew, Sarah Bruce, Tony Vyn, and Gary Peterson. 2004. “ Achievements and Future Challenges in Conservation Tillage.” Pp. 1–19 in Proceedings of the 4th International Crop Science Congress, Brisbane, Australia.
- Maaz, Tai, J. D. Wulfhorst, Vicki McCracken, John Kirkegaard, David R. Huggins, Ildiko Roth, Harsimran Kaur, and William Pan. 2018. “Economic, Policy, and Social Trends and Challenges of Introducing Oilseed and Pulse Crops into Dryland Wheat Cropping Systems.” Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 253: 177–94.
- Mase, Amber Saylor, Benjamin M. Gramig, and Linda Stalker Prokopy. 2017. “Climate Change Beliefs, Risk Perceptions, and Adaptation Behavior among Midwestern US Crop Farmers.” Climate Risk Management 15: 8–17.
- Morel, Kevin and François Léger. 2016. “A Conceptual Framework for Alternative Farmers' Strategic Choices: The Case of French Organic Market Gardening Microfarms.” Agroecology and Sustainable Food Systems 40(5): 466–92.
- Morton, Lois Wright, Jean M. McGuire, and Alicia D. Cast. 2017. “A Good Farmer Pays Attention to the Weather.” Climate Risk Management 15: 18–31.
- Naidoo, Rajani. 2004. “Fields and Institutional Strategy: Bourdieu on the Relationship between Higher Education, Inequality and Society.” British Journal of Sociology of Education 25(4): 457–71.
- Nail, Elizabeth L., Douglas L. Young, and William F. Schillinger. 2007. “Government Subsidies and Crop Insurance Effects on the Economics of Conservation Cropping Systems in Eastern Washington.” Agronomy Journal 99(3): 614–20.
- Natural Resources Conservation Service (NRCS). 2013. Unlock the Secrets in the Soil. Washington, DC: USDA.
- Peterson, Gary Andrew, Alan Jay Schlegel, Donald Lee Tanaka, and Oliver Randolph Jones.1996. “Precipitation Use Efficiency as Affected by Cropping and Tillage Systems.” Journal of Production Agriculture 9(2): 180–86.
- Peterson, Gary A., and Dwayne G. Westfall. 2004. “Managing Precipitation Use in Sustainable Dryland Agroecosystems.” Annals of Applied Biology 144(2): 127–38.
- Quinn, Courtney and Mark E. Burbach. 2008. Personal Characteristics Preceding Pro-environmental Behaviors that Improve Surface Water Quality. Great Plains Research 18: 103–14.
- Raedeke, Andrew H., John J. Green, Sandra S. Hodge, and Corinne Valdivia. 2003. “Farmers, the Practice of Farming and the Future of Agroforestry: An Application of Bourdieu's Concepts of Field and Habitus.” Rural Sociology 68(1): 64–86.
- Roesch-McNally, Gabrielle, J.Gordon Arbuckle, and John Charles Tyndall. 2018. “Soil as Social-Ecological Feedback: Examining the 'Ethic' of Soil Stewardship among Corn Belt Farmers.” Rural Sociology 83(1): 145–73.
- Rogers, Everett M. 2003. Diffusion of Innovations. New York, NY: Free Press.
- Rosenzweig, Steven T., Steven J. Fonte, and Meagan E. Schipanski. 2018. “Intensifying Rotations Increases Soil Carbon, Fungi, and Aggregation in Semi-arid Agroecosystems.” Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 258: 14–22.
- Rosenzweig, Steven T., Mary E. Stromberger, and Meagan E. Schipanski. 2018. “Intensified Dryland Crop Rotations Support Greater Grain Production with Fewer Inputs.” Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 264: 63–72.
- Saltiel, John, James W. Bauder, and Sandy Palakovich. 1994. “Adoption of Sustainable Agricultural Practices: Diffusion, Farm Structure, and Profitability.” Rural Sociology 59(2): 333–49.
- Shapiro, Barry Ira, B. Wade Brorsen, and D. Howard Doster. 1992. “Adoption of Double-Cropping Soybeans and Wheat.” Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics 24(2): 33–40.
10.1017/S0081305200018355 Google Scholar
- Shaver, Tim M., Gary A. Peterson, and Lucretia A. Sherrod. 2003. “Cropping Intensification in Dryland Systems Improves Soil Physical Properties: Regression Relations.” Geoderma 116(1): 149–64.
- Sherrod, Lucretia A., Gary A. Peterson, Dwayne G. Westfall, and Lajpat R. Ahuja. 2003. “Cropping Intensity Enhances Soil Organic Carbon and Nitrogen in a No-till Agroecosystem.” Soil Science Society of America Journal 67(5): 1533–43.
- Sherrod, Lucretia A., Gary A. Peterson, Dwayne G. Westfall, and Lajpat R. Ahuja. 2005. “Soil Organic Carbon Pools After 12 Years in No-till Dryland Agroecosystems.” Soil Science Society of America Journal 69(5): 1600–8.
- Smith, Elwin G., and Douglas L. Young. 2000. “The Economic and Environmental Revolution in Semi-arid Cropping in North America.” Annals of Arid Zone 39(3): 347–62.
- Sobels, Jonathan, Allan Curtis, and Stewart Lockie. 2001. “The Role of Landcare Group Networks in Rural Australia: Exploring the Contribution of Social Capital.” Journal of Rural Studies 17(3): 265–76.
- Strauss, Claudia. 2006. “The Imaginary.” Anthropological Theory 6(3): 322–44.
10.1177/1463499606066891 Google Scholar
- Strepanovic, Strahinja, Cody Creech, Dipak Santra, and Tony Adesemoye. 2016. Field Pea Production: Rotational Costs and Benefits. Lincoln, NE: University of Nebraska Lincoln.
- Stuart, Diana and Sean Gillon. 2013. “Scaling Up to Address New Challenges to Conservation on US Farmland.” Land Use Policy 31: 223–36.
- Sutherland, Lee-Ann and Rob J. F. Burton. 2011. “Good Farmers, Good Neighbours? The Role of Cultural Capital in Social Capital Development in a Scottish Farming Community.” Sociologia Ruralis 51(3): 238–55.
- Taylor, Charles. 2004. Modern Social Imaginaries. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
10.1215/9780822385806 Google Scholar
- Van der Ploeg, Jan Douwe. 2006. “ Agricultural Production in Crisis.” Pp. 258–77 in Handbook of Rural Studies, edited by Paul Cloke, Terry Marsden, and Patrick Mooney. London, England: Sage.
10.4135/9781848608016.n18 Google Scholar
- Warner, Keith Douglass. 2008. “Agroecology as Participatory Science: Emerging Alternatives to Technology Transfer Extension Practice.” Science, Technology, & Human Values 33(6): 754–77.
- Weber, Max. 1993. The Sociology of Religion. Boston, MA: Beacon Press.
- Wilson, Geoff A. 2001. “From Productivism to Post-Productivism … and Back Again? Exploring the (un) Changed Natural and Mental Landscapes of European Agriculture.” Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 26(1): 77–102.